Give this tooth pick activity a try!
I found these toothpick holders at Dollar Tree (3/$1) in the Luau section. They are a perfect fine motor skill activity. The lid has a small hole to put the toothpicks back into the container or you can turn it and it has 3 holes to put the toothpicks back in.
Need a challenge? Use tweezers to transfer the toothpicks back into the container.